
Building Belonging: What Sports Fandom Can Teach Us About Audience Belonging
Picture this: your favorite football team is facing its divisional nemesis at home. You don your Zubaz, grab your D-fence sign, and set off to the stadium to begin the requisite four hours of tailgating, complete with jumping through a folding table or two. Now let's say the good guys (for the unindoctrinated, the “good guys” in question are the Buffalo Bills) lay an egg and lose the game. Fans are now literally out thousands of dollars, often covered in condiments, and taking shade from the opposing team's fans while they sit in gridlock traffic to exit the stadium. And yet, fans will happily subject themselves to that experience eight times a year, not including playoffs or away games. Why? For arts organizations, it's worth asking what makes that experience worthwhile. What’s the secret sauce that makes game day special, no matter the result? And what can we learn from the extraordinary sense of community that sports fans build around the teams they love? Rather than asking only how to persuade someone to book again, we can — and should — ask what would make them feel part of our organization. It's About More Than the Game In 2025, a study of nearly 1,000 sports fans across the US and UK found an association between strong team identification and greater social wellbeing. Bills Mafia's Del Reid put it rather well: “I've always equated football with community. It's something that is shared.” That's a big part of what makes sports fandom so powerful. The game matters. But so do the people you watch it with, the traditions you share, and the feeling of being part of something that exists long before and after the final whistle. Arts, culture, and in-person experience organizations have an opportunity to create that same sense of connection. We often think about audience engagement as the relationship between an organization and an individual. But what about the relationships between audience members? There's a difference between enjoying a performance and looking forward to seeing familiar faces when you arrive. Recently, a friend invited me to a Red Sox game, using season tickets his family has held for years. What struck me was how much time he spent chatting with the couple next to us — friends he knows exclusively from their years as neighbors in Fenway Park’s right-field seats. Appreciating an organization is not the same as feeling that you're part of its community. Neither experience is more valid than the other. Not everyone wants to make friends at the theater, just as not every Bills fan wants to jump through a folding table. But for people who are looking for connection, the experience of being together can be as important as what brings them together in the first place. Belonging Begins With a Genuine Welcome Nobody becomes a devoted fan overnight. And before we can expect people to develop a sense of belonging, they need to feel that our spaces are for them in the first place. Culture Track's US research found that 46% of people who didn't visit art and design museums identified “it's not for someone like me” as a barrier to participation. Among people who didn't attend non-musical theater, 28% said the same. Those are important reminders that the experience of belonging begins before someone walks through the door. For someone attending for the first time, there may be all sorts of unfamiliar questions. Where do I go? What should I wear? Will I know what's happening? Will I feel comfortable coming on my own? And when they do arrive, the way they're welcomed can make all the difference. At Woodstock Arts in Georgia, the team has developed ways to recognize and welcome people at different stages of their relationship with the organization. First-time visitors receive an offer for the bar, while information about their previous interactions helps staff prepare personalized welcome notes and relevant benefits. The team can also recognize returning patrons and acknowledge their ongoing support across the site, from the box office to the bar and auditorium. These aren't grand gestures; they're simple but meaningful ways of showing people that they've been noticed, and that their presence matters. And that recognition can grow into something more lasting over time. Sometimes the Connection Is the Point One of my favorite examples comes from Salt Lake Acting Company in Utah. The team introduced online subscriptions, making it easier for patrons to renew without visiting the box office. But something interesting happened. People weren't necessarily taking up the convenient new option. It turned out that many of their subscribers actively enjoyed renewing in person. They liked talking to the team, catching up, and making that interaction part of their visit. As Nick Fleming, Director of Ticketing, explained: “Our audience loves talking to us, and we love talking to them.” Rather than trying to replace those conversations, the team found a way to put human connection at the center of their approach. Staff roamed the foyers, talked to patrons, and used mobile devices to complete subscriptions there and then. And the conversations became contagious. Friends and even strangers sitting nearby saw people subscribing and decided to join in. Nick's conclusion was simple: people come to cultural spaces looking for human interaction, and organizations shouldn't lose sight of that in their enthusiasm for digital convenience. And it's not difficult to see the parallel with sports. Fans don't necessarily want the fastest possible route from their front door to their stadium seat (though a clear path to the restrooms is always welcome). The conversations, familiar faces, and shared rituals are part of the day. From Attending to Feeling Part of Something There's another aspect of sports fandom that I find fascinating: the way people express their connection to a team. It might be a jersey, a bumper sticker, or an entire collection of Sabres dinnerware that defines your dining experience. (Zamboni gravy boat, anyone?) These things aren't what create the relationship. They're expressions of a relationship that already exists. For arts organizations, that sense of identification can take many different forms. At Cincinnati Shakespeare Company , known affectionately as Cincy Shakes, flexible subscriptions have long been part of the organization's approach to building lasting audience relationships. Jeanna Vella, Director of Marketing and Data Analytics, describes how a subscription can become more than a way to save money or book several performances. For some patrons, it's a way of expressing confidence in an organization they care about and want to support. A future fan of your venue may begin by buying a ticket for one particular production. With the right welcome and nurture, that initial interest can grow into regular attendance and deep attachment to the organization itself, its work and the community around it. And that attachment doesn't have to look the same for everyone. Some people will want to attend every production. Others might make a donation, bring a friend, or choose to subscribe because they believe in what the organization is doing. The question is how we recognize and value those different relationships, rather than expecting every audience member to demonstrate their loyalty in the same way. Make It Personal and Make It Meaningful Salvatore Prizio, Executive Director at Capitol Center for the Arts in New Hampshire, describes the importance of knowing the people who come through the organization's doors. His team knows patrons' favorite shows and drinks, and uses that knowledge to make their experiences more personal. As Salvatore puts it: “We know their favorite shows, we know their favorite drinks, and we can personalize their experience. They feel real ownership of everything that goes on here because they see our investment in them and their community.” He connects that feeling to the investment the organization makes in its audiences and the wider community. People don't simply feel connected because they've bought tickets or received a membership card. They feel connected when the relationship means something to them. And understanding that relationship requires more than knowing how frequently someone attends. The same person might come to a comedy show with friends, bring their family to a holiday production, and support a fundraising campaign because they care about the organization's place in their community. Each of those interactions tells us something, but none tells the whole story. A connected view of audience engagement can help organizations recognize those different motivations, while the knowledge and conversations that teams build up over time help them understand what the data alone can't explain. What Can We Learn From Bills Mafia? I'm not suggesting that theaters should introduce tailgating, or that we should expect audiences to demonstrate the kind of devotion that leads someone to sit through a Buffalo nor’easter watching Josh Allen hurdle linebackers (though I do highly recommend it). There are important differences between sports and the arts. And even within the arts, different people want very different things from their experiences. Some will come for a single production and have a wonderful time without ever returning. Others will build a relationship that lasts for decades. Both are worth celebrating. But I do think sports fandom offers a useful reminder of something we can overlook when we're focused on bookings, attendance and revenue. The experience isn't always just about what happens on stage, on screen, or in the gallery. It's also about the people we share it with, the welcome we receive, and the feeling that we have a place in something bigger. The most devoted sports fans don't just love their teams. They identify with them, and with one another. Arts organizations have the opportunity to build equally meaningful relationships, in ways that reflect their own purpose and the communities they serve. And if we can help more people feel that kind of connection, we might find that the reasons they come back go well beyond the next event on the calendar. After all, Bills Mafia wouldn't be Bills Mafia if we only showed up when we won. Read Understanding Every Individual to Engage and Grow Your Audience to explore how cultural participation can grow into a deeper sense of belonging. This article was sponsored by Spektrix.
